Conceptual framework for correlation of constitutional and administrative law

  • Yuliia Vashchenko Taras Shevchenko National University of Kyiv
Keywords: Constitutional Law, Administrative Law, Public Administration, Legal Institute, Legal System

Abstract

The article deals with issues of separation and cooperation of Constitutional and Administrative Law. On the basis of the Constitutional and Administrative correlation research conducted the recommendations on encouragement of efficient cooperation of such fields of the legal science and study disciplines have been developed.

Constitutional Law and Administrative Law are separate fields of law according to the predominant approach presented in the modern legal science. However, different criteria are used for the purposes of their separation and cooperation. It is concluded that Constitutional and Administrative Law have commonalities and differences. Both Constitutional Law and Administrative Law are fundamental fields of Public law; regulate social relations in the fields of executive power and public governance; based on common principles (e. g., rule of law, legality, separation of powers, etc.).

Based on the legislation of Ukraine and current scientific approaches it is summed up that Constitutional and Administrative Law can be separated, in particular, on the basis of such criteria as concretization/implementation, statics/dynamics, strategic/tactics, substantive/procedural character. Constitutional Law aims to stipulate the Fundamental Rights and Freedoms, defines the general framework of establishment and functioning of the public administration; meanwhile, Administrative Law aims to its specification and implementation. Constitutional Law primarily regulates static relations in the field of public administration activity (in particular, define the fundamental human rights and freedoms in the field of public administration activity, general framework of organization and activity of bodies of executive power and other subjects of public administration, etc.); Administrative Law regulates dynamic relations in the field of public administration activity (in particular, mechanisms of realization and protection of Human Rights, internal organizational activity of subjects of public administration, mechanisms of realization of their functions, tasks and responsibilities, etc.). Statics and dynamics of Constitutional and Administrative Law relatively also appear in fact that Constitutional Law is more stable, considering the stability of a constitution as one of its main features; meanwhile, Administrative

Law is more dynamic because of necessity of prompt reply to changes in state and society. To some extend Constitutional Law can be considered as strategic field of law, taking into consideration that the Constitution defines the legal road maps for the long prospective; meanwhile, Administrative Law prescribes the concrete mechanisms for their achievements. Thus, the majority of Constitutional Law norms are substantive norms; at the same time, Administrative Law mostly consists of procedural norms that integrated into substantive norms regarding public administration and regulation. It is suggested that the legal institute of a status of public administration to be considered as a mixed legal institute that exists at the confluence of Constitutional and Administrative Law.

It is stressed that the frames and logicality should be encouraged during teaching of study disciplines in Constitutional and Administrative Law. Administrative Law and Procedure should be taught upon completion of Constitutional Law and Procedure. Differences in Constitutional and Administrative Law have national peculiarities determined by the form of government, the content of the main law of a certain country, peculiarities of organization of the system of public administration, divergent character of Administrative Law etс. Therefore, the place of the border between Constitutional and Administrative Law in different countries may vary. It is emphasized that in frames of constitutional and public administration reforms that are currently in place in Ukraine, as well as European integration of our country the consolidated efforts of representatives of Constitutional and Administrative Law sciences are crucial for the development of scientifically proven designs of public administration organization and functioning, as well as mechanisms of realization and protection of human rights and freedoms.

References

Nauka administratsii y administratyvnoho prava. Zahalna chastyna (za vykladamy profesora Yuriia Paneika) / Ukladachi: V. M. Bevzenko, I. B. Koliushko, O. R. Radyshevska, I. S. Hrytsenko, P. B. Stetsiuk. — Kyiv : VD «Dakor», 2016. — 464 s.

Konstytutsiine pravo zarubizhnykh krain: navch. posibnyk / V. O. Riiaka, V. S. Semenov, M. V. Tsvik ta in.; za zah. red. V. O. Riiaky. — K. : Yurinkom Inter, 2002. — 512 s.

Frytskyi O. F. Konstytutsiine pravo Ukrainy : Pidruchnyk / O. F. Frytskyi — K. : Yurinkom Inter, 2004. — 2-e vyd., pererob. ta dopov. — 510 s.

Stetsenko S. H. Administratyvne pravo Ukrainy : navch. posib. / S. H. Stetsenko — vyd. 2-he, pererobl. ta dopovn. — K.: Atika, 2009. — 640 s.

Kurs administratyvnoho prava Ukrainy : pidruchnyk / V. K. Kolpakov, O. V. Kuzmenko, I. D. Pastukh, V. D. Sushchenko ta in. — 2-he vyd., pererob. i dopov. — K. : Yurinkom Inter, 2013. — 872 s.

Administratyvne pravo Ukrainy [pidruchnyk dlia yuryd. vuziv i fak.] / Yu. P. Bytiak, V. V. Bohutskyi, V. M. Harashchuk ta in.; za zah. red. Yu. P. Bytiaka. — Kharkiv : Pravo, 2001. — 528 s.

Rossynskyi B. V. Admynystratyvnoe pravo : uchebnyk / B. V. Rossynskyi, Yu. M. Starylov. — 4-e yzd., peresmotr. Y dop. — M. : Norma, 2009. — 928 s.

Shkolyk A. M. Porivnialne administratyvne pravo : navch. posibnyk dlia yurydychnykh fakultetiv ta fakultetiv mizhnarodnykh vidnosyn / A. M. Shkolyk. — Lviv : ZUKTs, 2007. — 308 s.

Premont M.-S. Administrative Law / Encyclopedic Dictionary of Public Administration: The reference for understanding government action / M.-S. Premont [Elektronnyi resurs]. — Rezhym dostupu : http:// www.dictionnaire.enap.ca/dictionnaire/docs/definitions/definitions_anglais/administrative_law.pdf.

Melnyk R. S. Systema administratyvnoho prava : dys. na zdob. nauk. stup. d-ra yuryd. nauk : 12.00.07 / R. S. Melnyk. — Kh, 2010. — 417 s.

Rose-Ackerman S. Comparative Administrative Law: Outlining a Field of Study (2010). Faculty Scholarship Series. Paper 4154 / S. Rose-Ackerman [Elektronnyi resurs]. — Rezhym dostupu : http://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/fss_papers/415.

Bignami F. Comparative Administrative Law / F. Bignami [Elektronnyi resurs]. — Rezhym dostupu : http://www.dphu.org/uploads/attachements/books/books_3830_0.pdf.

Aver’ianov Vadym Borysovych. Vybrani naukovi pratsi / Uporiadnyky: Andriiko O. F. (kerivnyk kolektyvu), Nahrebelnyi V. P., Kysil L. Ye., Pedko Yu. S., Derets V. A., Pukhtetska A. A., Kirmach A. V., Liulka L. V. Za zah. red. : Yu. S. Shemshuchenka, O. F. Andriiko. — K. : Instytut derzhavy i prava im. V. M. Koretskoho NAN Ukrainy, 2011. — 448 s.

Koval L. Administratyvne pravo Ukrainy / L. Koval. — K. : Osnovy. — 154 s.

Gildenhuys JCH. The philosophy of public administration: a holistic approach / JCH Gildenhuys [Elektronnyi resurs]. — Rezhym dostupu : https://books.google.com.ua/books?id=SmIyAwAAQBAJ&pg=PA94&dq=while+constitutional+law+deals+in+general+with+the+power+and+structure&hl=uk&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjL8oiitKvPAhXlIpoKHaFRDagQ6AEIHDAA#v=onepage&q=while%20constitutional%20law%20deals%20in%20general%20with%20the%20power%20and%20structure&f=false.

Yohannes A., Michael D. G. Administrative Law: Teaching Material, 2009 / A. Yohannes, D. G. Michael [Elektronnyi resurs]. — Rezhym dostupu : https://chilot.files.wordpress.com/2011/06/administrativelaw.pdf.

Ginsburg T. Written Constitutions and the Administrative State: On the Constitutional Character of Administrative Law / T. Ginsburg // University of Chicago Public Law &Legal Theory Working Paper. — No.331. — 2010. — P.117.

Chykurlii S. O. Konstytutsiino-pravovyi status orhaniv vykonavchoi vlady Ukrainy : aref. dys. na zdob. nauk. stup. kand. yuryd. nauk : 12.00.02 / S. O. Chykurlii. — K., 2008. — 22 s.

Sovhyria O. V. Konstytutsiino-pravovyi status Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy: suchasnyi stan ta tendentsii rozvytku : monohrafiia / O. V. Sovhyria. — K. : Yurinkom Inter, 2012. — 464 s.

Konstytutsiia Ukrainy: pryiniata na p’iatii sesii Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy 28 chervnia 1996 roku (iz zminamy ta dopovnenniamy) // Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. – 1996. – № 30. – St. 141.

Administratyvne pravo Ukrainy. Akademichnyi kurs: Pidruch.: U dvokh tomakh: Tom 1. Zahalna chastyna / Red. kolehiia: V. B. Aver’ianov (holova). — K. : Vydavnytstvo «Iurydychna dumka», 2004. — 584 s.

Pro tsentralni orhany vykonavchoi vlady: Zakon Ukrainy vid 17 berez. 2011 r. № 3166-VI (iz zminamy ta dopovnenniamy) // Ofitsiinyi visnyk Ukrainy. – 2011. – № 27. – St.1123.

Vashchenko Yu. V. Administratyvno-pravovyi status enerhetychnoho rehuliatora v Ukraini: suchasnyi stan ta perspektyvy reformuvannia u konteksti yevropeiskoi intehratsii : monohrafiia / Yu. V. Vashchenko. — K. : Yurinkom Inter, 2015. — 288 s.

Melnyk R. S. Do pytannia pro pravovyi status natsionalnykh komisii rehuliuvannia pryrodnykh monopolii / R. S. Melnyk, Ye. V. Petrov / Administratyvne pravo i protses. — 2012. — № 2(2). — S. 8–14.

Shmidt-Assmann E. Zahalne administratyvne pravo yak ideia vrehuliuvannia: osnovni zasady ta zavdannia systematyky administratyvnoho prava / E. Shmidt-Assmann; [per. z nim. H. Ryzhkov, I. Soiko, A. Bakanov]; vidp. red. O. Syroid. — [2-he vyd., pereroblene ta dopovnene]. — K. : «K. I.S.», 2009. — 552 s.

Alekseev S. S. Struktura sovetskoho prava / S. S. Alekseev. — M. : Yuryd. Lyt., 1975. — 264 s.

Sovhyria O. V. Konstytutsiine pravo Ukrainy: navch. posibnyk / O. V. Sovhyria, N. H. Shuklina. — K. : Yurinkom Inter, 2007. — 632 s.

University of Southampton. Constitutional and Administrative Law: Module Overview [Elektronnyi resurs]. — Rezhym dostupu : http://www.southampton.ac.uk/law/undergraduate/modules/laws1013_constitutional_law_and_administrative_law.page#syllabus.

Barnett H., Diamantides M. Public Law / H. Barnett, M. Diamantides [Elektronnyi resurs]. — Rezhym dostupu : http://www.londoninternational.ac.uk/sites/default/files/programme_resources/laws/ug_subject_guides/public_law-subjectguide4chapters.pdf.

University of Adelaide. Course Outlines. Principles of Public Law [Elektronnyi resurs]. — Rezhym dostupu : https://www.adelaide.edu.au/course-outlines/104991/1/sem-2.

Australian National University. Course Australian Public Law [Elektronnyi resurs]. — Rezhym dostupu : http://programsandcourses.anu.edu.au/course/LAWS1205.

Using Administrative Law Tools and Concepts to Strengthen USAID Programming: A Guide for USAID Democracy and Governance Officers [Elektronnyi resurs]. — Rezhym dostupu : http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/Pnadk999.pdf
Published
2019-02-22
How to Cite
Vashchenko, Y. (2019). Conceptual framework for correlation of constitutional and administrative law. Administrative Law and Process, (3(17), 21-35. Retrieved from https://applaw.net/index.php/journal/article/view/98
Section
General administrative law