ORGANIZATIONAL FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO VIOLATIONS OF TRANSPORT OPERATION RULES

Keywords: transport safety, criminal law aspects, transport, transport violations, transport infrastructure, administrative, legal aspects, regulatory framework

Abstract

Purpose. This research aims to comprehensively analyze the organizational factors that directly influence violations of transport operation rules in Ukraine. The main goal is to identify key institutional, managerial, and systemic factors leading to increased transport violations and develop scientifically-based recommendations for minimizing their negative impact on transport infrastructure safety. The study also focuses on identifying cause-and-effect relationships between organizational deficiencies and the level of transport accidents, enabling a comprehensive approach to solving the problem considering the specifics of different transport modes and regional features of Ukraine's transport system. Methods. The study applies a systematic approach using general scientific and unique cognitive methods. A comparative legal analysis of Ukrainian regulatory acts in transport safety was conducted, a statistical analysis of data on transport operation violations for 2020-2025 was performed, and systems analysis methods were used to identify relationships between various factors and their impact on transport system safety. Additionally, expert assessment methods were applied, involving transport industry specialists, representatives of regulatory bodies, and scientists, which provided a comprehensive view of the problem from different professional perspectives. Sociological research methods were also used to determine the level of legal awareness among transport process participants and their attitudes toward compliance with transport operation rules. Results. Based on the analysis, it was established that the key organizational factors contributing to violations of transport operation rules are imperfections in the monitoring system for compliance with vehicle operation requirements, ineffective coordination between different transport industry regulatory bodies, gaps in regulatory and legal frameworks, insufficient personnel qualifications, and low level of professional training of transport enterprise employees. Criminal and administrative legal aspects of liability for violations of transport operation rules were analyzed, revealing systemic problems in accountability mechanisms. It was also found that a significant impact on the level of infringements comes from outdated material and technical base of transport enterprises, insufficient funding for transport infrastructure modernization programs, and lack of effective mechanisms to stimulate investment in transport safety. Special attention was paid to analyzing the effectiveness of the existing system of training and professional development of transport industry workers, as well as assessing the impact of digitalization and implementation of modern technologies on the safety level of Ukraine's transport system. Conclusions. A set of recommendations has been developed to improve organizational and legal mechanisms for preventing violations of transport operation rules, which includes optimization of the monitoring and control system for safety requirements compliance, implementation of innovative technologies in the transport infrastructure management system, improvement of the regulatory framework and its harmonization with international standards, enhancement of personnel training, and implementation of an effective staff motivation system.

References

1. Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine (2020) Law of Ukraine «On Transport». Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy, no. 51, art. 446.
2. Petrenko, O.M. (2022) Regulation of the Transport Industry in Ukraine: Problems andProspects. Kyiv: Yurydychna Dumka.
3. Kovalenko, T.V. (2023) Implementation of European Standards in the Transport Legislation of Ukraine. Pravo Ukrainy, no. 3, pp. 45–57.
4. Ministry of Infrastructure of Ukraine (2023) Annual Report on the State of the Transport Industry of Ukraine. Kyiv.
5. National Police of Ukraine (2023) Statistical Data on Transport Violations for 2020–2022. Kyiv.
6. Ukrainian Institute of Transport Safety (2023) Forecast of Violations of Transport Operation Rules for 2023–2025. Kyiv.
7. Department of Patrol Police of Ukraine (2023) Analysis of the Structure of Vehicle Operation Rule Violations. Kyiv.
8. Kovalchuk, V.M. and Sydorenko, S.O. (2024) The Connection Between Violations of Transport Operation Rules and Road Accidents. Scientific Bulletin of the National Academy of Internal Affairs, no. 1, pp. 112–124.
9. State Service of Ukraine for Transport Safety (2023) Economic Consequences of Violations of Transport Operation Rules. Kyiv.
10. Ministry of Infrastructure of Ukraine (2024) Industry Distribution of Violations of Transport Operation Rules. Kyiv.
11. Institute of Transport Problems of Ukraine (2023) Safety Management Systems at Transport Enterprises of Ukraine: Current State. Kyiv.
12. Melnychenko, O.P. (2024) Economic Determinants of Violations of Transport Operation Rules in Ukraine. Economics of Transport, no. 2, pp. 67–78.
13. Honcharenko, I.V. and Petrova, K.L. (2023) Problems of Personnel Qualification in the Transport Industry of Ukraine. Personnel Management, no. 5, pp. 34–46.
14. Department of Patrol Police of Ukraine (2023) Technical Condition of Commercial Carrier Vehicles: Inspection Results. Kyiv.
15. Criminal Code of Ukraine (2021) Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy, no. 25–26, art. 131.
16. Office of the Prosecutor General of Ukraine (2023) Statistical Information on Registered Criminal Offenses for 2020–2023. Kyiv.
17. Ivanenko, M.S. and Petruk, O.V. (2023) Criminal Liability for Violations of Transport Operation Rules. Law and Security, no. 3, pp. 89–101.
18. European Transport Forum (2024) Comparative Analysis of Transport Safety in Europe. Brussels.
19. Dniprovsky, O. et al. (2023) Legal Challenges of Modern Transport Technologies in Ukraine. Kyiv: Liha-Pres.
20. Savchenko, V. (2024) Fragmentation of Transport Legislation: Risks and Solutions. Journal of European Law, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 45–60.
Published
2025-05-30
How to Cite
Riabykh, N. (2025). ORGANIZATIONAL FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO VIOLATIONS OF TRANSPORT OPERATION RULES. Administrative Law and Process, (1), 47-60. https://doi.org/10.32782/2227-796X.2025.1.05
Section
Special administrative law