The claim to attention of human dignity in relation to the displacement of the population: Germany’s experience

  • Viktoria Savchuk Georg-August University of Goettingen
Keywords: expellees, displaced persons, human rights protection, recognition of displaced persons, compensation rights, administrative procedural law

Abstract

Purpose. In this article, the special administrative features of the determination of the expellee’s status will be analysed through the prism of human dignity as well as their use of rights and advantages according to German expellee law (the Federal expellee law, the version of 19May 1953) as a result of the expulsion of Germans from East Europe to Germany (later – the Federal Republic of Germany) from 1945–1949.

Methods. Questions regarding the determination of the characteristic of the expellees as well as the use of rights and privileges of the displaced person according to German expellee law are determined by the teleological interpretation, the interpretation as per the wording of the Federal Expellees Law (Paragraphs 1 and 9 of the BVFG – Displaced Person’s Property – the prerequisite for the use of rights and benefits) and through the systematic and historical analysis of the development.

Results. The respect and protection of human dignity as one of the core constitutional principles and the protect on of the subjective rights of the some of the most vulnerable people, such as those who are displaced constitute good indicators on the legal and practical levels for measuring the degree of democracy, legality, human rights, and social justice in a state.

The question regarding espect for human dignity of those who are displaced, as discussion, is raised not only in relation to the actual exercise of rights, but already exists in relation to the recognition of the status of the displaced person and that person’s access to the special rights and benefits which balance the status. The conforming to human dignity of the corresponding state regulation in these phases in decisive for the continued existence of the displaced persons at their place of admission, their legal status, and their inclusive participation in social and political affairs.

The in-depth analysis of the legislation on displaced persons in Germany leads to the following conclusion – to the list of vital requisites for the respect of the human dignity of the expellees and to the critical points, and thereby the problem in the sense of respect for human dignity for displaced persons in Germany was crystallised.

Conclusions. In conclusion, it is pointed out that the scientific analysis of human displacement is a complicated phenomenon which, because of its relevance in the world, plays an essential role and requires further research.

References

1. Benthin, M. (2007). Die Vertreibung der Deutschen aus Ostmitteleuropa. Deutsche und tschechische Erinnerungskulturen im Vergleich [The expulsion of Germans from East Central Europe. German and Czech memory cultures in comparison]. Vol. 120. Hannover: Verlag Hahnsche Buchhandlung [in German].

2. Berg, W. (2011). Staatsrecht: Grundriss des Staatsorganisationsrechts und der Grundrechte [Constitutional Law: Outline of State Organization Law and Fundamental Rights]. 6th ed. Stuttgart: Richard Boorberg Verlag [in German].

3. Bohn, R. (1997). Die deutsche Herrschaft in den „germanischen Ländern“1940–1945 (Historische Mitteilungen, Beihefte, Band 26) [German rule in the “Germanic countries” 1940–1945 (Historic releases, supplements, Volume 26)]. 1th ed. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag [in German].

4. Häuser, O., Kapinos, A., & Christ, R. (1990). Die Statusfeststellung nach dem Bundesvertriebenengesetz: Kommentar [The status determination according to the federal expellee law: Commentaries]. Stuttgart: Verlag W. Kohlhammer [in German].

5. Kossert, A., & Kalte, H. (2008). Die Geschichte der deutschen Vertriebenennach 1945 [Cold home. The history of German expellees after 1945]. München: Siedler Verlag [in German].

6. Liesner, E. (1988). Aussiedler. Die Voraussetzungen für die Anerkennung als Vertriebener. Arbeitshandbuch für Behörden, Gerichte und Verbände [Resettlers. The conditions for recognition as a displaced person. Working manual for authorities, courts and associations]. Herford; Bonn: Maximilian-Verlag [in German].

7. Locke, J. (1967). Zwei Abhandlungen über die Regierung [Two treatises of government]. W. Euchner (ed.). Frankfurt am Main: Europäische Verlagsanstalt [in German].

8. Mangoldt, H. v., Klein, F., & Starck, C. (2018). Kommentar zum Grundgesetz: GG [Comment on the Basic Law: GG]. Vol. 3. A. Vosskuhle, P.M. Huber (eds.). 7th ed. München : C.H. BECK, 2018 [in German].

9. Neuhoff, H. (1977). Die deutschen Vertriebenen in Zahlen [German expellees in figures]. Bonn [in German].

10. Prütting, H., Wegen, G., & Weinreich, G. (2018). BGB Kommentar (13. Auflage) & ZPO Kommentar (10. Auflage) [Civil Law Book Commentaries (13th edition) & Commentary on the Swiss Code of Civil Procedure (10th edition)]. Luchterhand [in German].

11. Rauschning, D. (1989). Rechtsstellung Deutschlands: völkerrechtliche Verträge und andere rechtsgestaltende Akte [Legal status of Germany: international treaties and other legal acts]. 2th ed. München: Dt. Taschenbuch-Verlag [in German].

12. Strassmann, W., & Nitsche, W. (1958). Bundesvertriebenengesetz. Kommentar mit Kennzifferverzeichnis und Sachregister [Federal Refugees Act. Comment with code number index and subject index]. 2th ed. München; Berlin: C.H. Beck [in German].

13. Thomas, F. (1950). Das Recht der Vertriebenen (von den Flüchtlingsgesetzen der Länder zum Bundes-Vertriebenengesetz) [The right of the expellees: (from the refugee laws of the federal states to the federal expellee law)]. Dortmund: Verlag „Soziale Welt“ [in German].

14. Wittreck, F. (2008). Grundgesetz – Kommentar [Basic Law – Commentaries]. Vol. III. H. Dreier (ed.). 2th ed. München [in German].

15. Bundesministerium für Vertriebene, Flüchtlinge und Kriegsgeschädigte (1960). Zeittafel. Band 2: Vertriebenenproblem, Recht auf die Heimat und Selbstbestimmung im Deutschen Parlament (von 1949 bis Mitte 1960) [Chronology. Volume 2: Displaced persons problem, right to the homeland and self-determination in the German Parliament (from 1949 to mid-1960)]. Bonn [in German].
Published
2019-06-10
How to Cite
Savchuk, V. (2019). The claim to attention of human dignity in relation to the displacement of the population: Germany’s experience. Administrative Law and Process, (1(24), 70-83. https://doi.org/10.17721/2227-796X.2019.1.07
Section
Foreign administrative law and procedure