The doctrine description of administrative legal disputes in foreign countries

  • Dmytro Yavdokymenko Classical Private University
Keywords: administrative legal dispute, administrative law, administrative justice, public laws, administrative court, point of claim, public administration

Abstract

The author carries out in the article the comparatively-legal analysis of doctrines of administrative legal disputes in countries with the proclaimed democratic modes, an estimation of essence and nature of administrative legal disputes, investigates theories administrative legal disputes in foreign countries, and also analyses the development of the institute of administrative justice.

It should be noted, estimating the features of organization and process of consideration of administrative legal disputes in different countries, that German and French legislative and legal practice moved up farther in all as compared to other European countries. Creation of the specialized courts as financial, social and other court bodies can fully consist in the legal doctrine of countries with the developed democracy. For creation of the specialized courts the public relations served by them must attain the certain quality level of development. This level must be determined by not only complication of public relations within the framework of that there are administrative legal disputes but also social meaningfulness of these relations among other relations of administrative legal type. The harmonization and unitization of the legal systems within the framework of European community require a development of some administrative legal concepts, not except and concept of administrative legal dispute and at international legal level.

References

Admynystratyvnaia yustytsyia v novыkh evropeiskykh demokratyiakh: Prakt. yssled. v sfere adm. prava y protsessa v Bolharyy, Эstonyy, Venhryy, Polshe y Ukrayne / pod red. D. Hallyhana y dr. — Kyev: ArtЭk, — Budapesht: OSY/KOLPY. 2009. — 688 s.

Admynystratyvnoe pravo zarubezhnыkh stran. M., 1996. — 260 s.

Barabashev H. V. Predyslovye k knyhe D. Harnera «Velykobrytanyia: tsentralnoe y mestnoe upravlenye». M., 1984. — 120 s.

Vedel Zh. Admynystratyvnoe pravo Frantsyy. M.: Prohress, 1973. — 198 c.

Harner D. Velykobrytanyia: tsentralnoe y mestnoe upravlenye. M. : Prohress, 1984. — 320 s.

Ehorov S. A. Polytycheskaia yurysprudentsyia v SShA. M.: Nauka, 1989. — 190 s.

Zhalynskyi A., Rёrykht A. Vvedenye v nemetskoe pravo. M.: Spark, 2001. — 210 s.

Knemaier F. L. Orhanyzatsyia mestnoho samoupravlenyia v Bavaryy (Osnovnыe strukturы, osobennosty, nedostatky) // Hosudarstvo y pravo. — 1995. — № 4. — S. 118–121.

Mytskevych L. A. Poniatye hosudarstvennoho upravlenyia v admynystratyvnom prave Hermanyy // Hosudarstvo y pravo. — 2002. — № 6. — S. 85–90.

Nykerov H. Y. Admynystratyvnoe pravo SShA. M.: Nauka, 1977. — 415 s.

Starylov Yu. N. Admynystratyvnaia yustytsyia. Problemы teoryy. Voronezh, 1998. — 255 s.

Starylov Yu. N. Admynystratyvnoe sudoproyzvodstvo (iustytsyia) v Hermanyy: ystoryia razvytyia y osnovnыe chertы // Hosudarstvo y pravo. — 1999. — № 7. — S. 72–76.

Starylov Yu. N. Kak razvyvalas nauka admynystratyvnoho prava v evropeiskykh stranakh. Zhurnal rossyiskoho prava. — 1999. — № 3–4. — S. 202–208.

Yuldashev A. R. Fynansovыe sudы v Hermanyy. M.: Anykl, 2000. — 198 s.

Gneist R. Die Englische Communal-Verfassung oder das System des Self-Government. Berlin, 1860. — 510 s.

Chapus R. Droit du contentieux administratif. Paris: Montchrestien, 1996. — 265 p.
Published
2019-02-22
How to Cite
Yavdokymenko, D. (2019). The doctrine description of administrative legal disputes in foreign countries. Administrative Law and Process, (3(17), 121-132. Retrieved from https://applaw.net/index.php/journal/article/view/110
Section
Special administrative law